Wednesday, August 14, 2013
American Tower Corporation has appealed Hood River County Planning Department’s decision to deny the Massachusetts-based company’s proposal to build a 160-foot cellphone tower on private land off of Fairview Drive in Hood River.
The Planning Department denied the application July 23 after determining the cell tower, which would have been disguised to look like a Douglas fir, was “not compatible with the surrounding area based on the impact it would have on the area’s visual character,” according to the decision written by Planning Director Mike Benedict, who also noted the height of the tower “was excessive compared to everything else around it.”
The proposal to build the cell tower, which would have been utilized primarily by AT&T, drew the ire of dozens of citizens last year who spoke out against the project during the public comment period. Many were neighbors living near the project site — a 10-acre parcel at 3790 Fairview Drive that’s owned by Jeff Blackman and Erin Burnham — who were concerned that the tower would be much taller than surrounding trees and negatively impact their views.
In the appeal letter dated Aug. 2, Bonnie Belair, counsel for ATC, countered that the tower “will be in proportion to some trees in the area,” and added that, “due to FCC (Federal Communications Commission) regulatory requirements, AT&T is required to fill gaps in coverage and capacity to provide cellular service in Hood River County.”
Belair cited the FCC’s Telecommunications Act of 1996 and case law in the appeal letter to argue for the Planning Department’s decision to be overturned.
“The TCA does provide authority to approve a proposed wireless communications facility in the event local or state laws ‘prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the provision of personal wireless services,’” she wrote. “In order to establish that a permit denial is tantamount to a prohibition in violation of TCA, the Applicant must provide evidence in the record supporting a two-part test: (1) the proposed facility closes a significant gap in the provider’s own coverage; and (2) the manner in which it proposes to fill the significant gap in service is the least intrusive (site location and design) on the values that the denial sought to serve.”
By selecting a tower disguised as a Douglas fir, known as a mono-fir design, Belair said ATC chose a design that would “minimize visual impact,” as opposed to building a traditional tower. She also noted the mono-fir would eliminate “the unnecessary proliferation of towers” by allowing other cell providers to use the structure in an arrangement known as collocation.
With the Planning Department’s decisions governed in part by the National Scenic Area Act of 1986, the appeal may put to the test which federal law trumps which. A public hearing has been scheduled for Wednesday, Aug. 28, at 7 p.m. in the Hood River County Board of Commissioners meeting room at 601 State St. for the Planning Commission to consider the appeal. Public comment on the cell tower proposal and appeal, both written and oral, is allowed.
More like this story
- The Porch for May 20
- Columbia Center offers Summer Arts class scholarships
- HR Valley Residents Committee: ‘Long-term watchdogs’ celebrate Sunday
- Parkdale teacher wins ‘Math Excellence Award’
- Letters to the Editor for May 20
- Morrison Park: Yes to re-zone, but dig in first
- Another Voice: Mexico: my thoughts and personal experiences
- Police Log, April 24 to May 14
- ‘No’ on NORCOR bond, close races for Port, Schools
- Moro: Azure weed plan takes root
I Can't Keep Quiet singers at "Citizen Town Hall"
‘I can’t keep quiet,’ sing members of an impromptu choir in front of Hood River Middle School Saturday prior to the citizen town hall for questions to Rep. Greg Walden. The song addresses female empowerment generally and sexual violence implicitly, and gained prominence during the International Women’s Day events in January. The singers braved a sudden squall to finish their song and about 220 people gathered in HRMS auditorium, which will be the scene of the April 12 town hall with Rep. Greg Walden, at 3 p.m. Enlarge